A printer purchase is one of the rare cases where the upfront price is less important than the ongoing running cost. Consumer testing consistently shows that cheap printers can cost several times more per page over their useful life than slightly pricier models with better ink efficiency. These five printers earned top positions in current consumer data by combining reliable print quality with operating costs that do not erode the value of every page printed.
| Product | Best For | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Epson EcoTank ET-4850 | Lowest ink cost overall | 4.9/5 |
| Brother HL-L2395DW | Laser text quality | 4.7/5 |
| Canon PIXMA TS9521C | Photo and craft printing | 4.6/5 |
| HP OfficeJet Pro 9015e | Home office all-in-one | 4.6/5 |
| Brother MFC-J4335DW | Ink tank all-in-one | 4.5/5 |
Epson EcoTank ET-4850 — Best Overall
The Epson EcoTank ET-4850 earns consistent top placement in consumer testing by solving the ink cost problem that undermines most inkjet printers. Refillable ink tanks come pre-filled with up to two years of ink supply in the box, and replacement bottles cost a fraction of cartridge equivalents. Consumer testers calculated per-page costs among the lowest of any inkjet model regardless of price tier. Print quality on both text and color documents is strong enough for professional documents, and photo output from the four-color system produces accurate color at borderless 4x6 through letter size. The all-in-one design includes flatbed scanning, copying, and fax capability. Wireless connectivity and a four-inch color touchscreen round out a package that consumer testing consistently recommends as the best long-term printer investment in its class.
Shop Epson EcoTank ET-4850 on Amazon
Brother HL-L2395DW — Best Laser for Text
The Brother HL-L2395DW is the top recommendation in consumer testing for users who primarily print text documents and want laser speed and sharpness at the lowest entry laser price. The 2400 x 600 dpi laser engine produces crisp text at letter and legal size that outshines any inkjet alternative at comparable prices. Print speeds reach 36 pages per minute for standard text, and the automatic duplex printing keeps paper costs controlled for high-volume jobs. The 250-sheet input tray reduces paper refill frequency. Wireless connectivity and a cloud print option cover most home and small office workflow needs. Toner cartridges have a high-yield version that drops per-page cost below most competitors in the entry laser tier. Not suited for color printing or photos, but unbeatable for monochrome text volume at its price.
Shop Brother HL-L2395DW laser printer on Amazon
Canon PIXMA TS9521C — Best for Photo Printing
The Canon PIXMA TS9521C is the top consumer-tested printer for households that prioritize photo output quality alongside standard document printing. The six-ink system includes a gray ink cartridge that improves tonal range in black-and-white photos and adds depth to color images that four-ink systems cannot match. Consumer testers rated borderless photo output at 4x6 through 11x17 (tabloid) size as among the most accurate in the consumer inkjet category. The wide-format capability makes it particularly valuable for photographers who print larger display prints at home. Document print quality is competitive with standard four-color alternatives. Wireless and AirPrint connectivity are included. The individual ink cartridge system reduces waste by allowing per-color replacement when one depletes.
Shop Canon PIXMA TS9521C on Amazon
HP OfficeJet Pro 9015e — Best Home Office All-in-One
The HP OfficeJet Pro 9015e is the strongest consumer-tested choice for home office users who need a single device to cover printing, scanning, copying, and faxing at professional output quality. The dual-band Wi-Fi and automatic document feeder that handles up to 35 sheets make workflow in a home office setting faster than consumer-grade alternatives. Print quality for text and business graphics is strong, with color accuracy that consumer testers found suitable for professional proposals and client documents. Print speeds at 22 pages per minute are competitive for an inkjet all-in-one. HP+ subscription unlocks additional ink delivery and cloud features. Individual ink cartridges prevent waste from combined cartridge designs. The Smart Tasks feature automates multi-step print-scan-send workflows from a touchscreen panel.
Shop HP OfficeJet Pro 9015e on Amazon
Brother MFC-J4335DW — Best Budget Ink Tank All-in-One
The Brother MFC-J4335DW brings the ink tank refill model to an all-in-one at a lower entry price than the Epson EcoTank alternatives, making it the top consumer-tested choice for budget-conscious buyers who want low running costs alongside scan, copy, and fax capability. The INKvestment Tank system provides up to one year of ink in the box, and replacement ink bottles cost significantly less than cartridge equivalents. Consumer testers found text quality competitive with standard inkjet alternatives in this price range and color quality adequate for everyday documents and basic photo printing. The 20-sheet automatic document feeder handles multi-page scan and copy jobs. Wireless connectivity and mobile printing support are included. Not the highest output quality in the category, but the ink cost structure makes it the most economical all-in-one in consumer data at this price tier.
Shop Brother MFC-J4335DW on Amazon
How to Choose a Printer
Start with your primary print type: text-heavy document printing favors laser, while photo and color document printing favors inkjet. For infrequent home printing, ink tank models prevent the dried-cartridge problem that plagues standard inkjet users who leave printers idle for weeks. For heavy office use, laser remains the fastest and most cost-efficient per page for monochrome. All-in-one designs add scanning and copying capability with minimal footprint increase. Check paper size support if you print anything larger than letter. Finally, factor in the cost of replacement ink or toner before finalizing your decision — the purchase price is often less than two years of consumable costs.
For related office and tech picks, see our best consumer reports OLED TV guide or explore our best compact all-in-one color laser printer roundup. For details on how we evaluate products, visit our methodology page.
Frequently asked questions
Inkjet or laser printer: which is better for home use?+
For home users who print infrequently, an inkjet printer with a high-yield ink tank or individual ink cartridges is generally more practical than a laser printer. Laser printers produce sharp text and handle high-volume print jobs efficiently, but they cost more upfront and are less suited to occasional photo printing. Consumer testing data suggests ink tank inkjet printers now offer the lowest per-page cost for mixed home printing, surpassing entry laser models in cost efficiency.
What is the real cost of printer ink, and how can I reduce it?+
Printer ink is among the most expensive liquids by volume sold in consumer products. The most cost-effective approach in consumer testing is to choose a printer that uses either individual color cartridges, so you replace only the depleted color, or an ink tank system that refills from inexpensive bottles. Printers that use combined color cartridges waste ink from the colors that remain when one depletes. High-yield cartridge versions of the same model consistently reduce per-page costs by 40 to 60 percent over standard cartridges.